The Same Old Story—India Lose

How many times has this happened in the recent past where India wins one test and lets the opposition come back in the next? I cannot fathom why this happens—-I would not like to parrot the standard “they lost their intensity, they got complacent” because I do not think that professionals “lose intensity”———–there is too much at stake. My explanation is that we consistently have this mindset that now that we have gone 1 up we should play for a draw. In other words take the minimum amount of risk possible in the next match and things will work out just fine.

Perhaps it makes sense on paper but history has shown us——–it never works. In Australia in 2003, in Pakistan in 2003, in Sri Lanka in 2002 we have always lost the initiative when have sought to maintain it. And that is because in cricket refusing to take risks means defeat. Inevitable, total defeat. Yet the Indian think tank refuses to learn from its past mistakes. Evidence: the latest debacle at Bangalore.

What were they thinking? After Sehwag got out, the Indian team, for no rhyme or reason, downed the shutters and refused to score. In other words they felt that offering a dead bat to everything was the best way to play for a draw. It is elementary cricketing knowledge which says that it is not. The fielding captain can crowd men around the bat, the bowlers are running in faster, the fielders are more interested… just tightens the noose.

This is precisely what happened after Sehwag got dismissed. It just seemed that the rest of India’s vaunted batting line up did not have the confidence to aggressively pursue the target.
So batsman after batsman stuck out their pads, totally stopped scoring—not even taking advantage of waist high full tosses.

And with the regularity of the victims in “Ten Little Indians” they fell one by one in similar fashion.

Some numbers:

Dravid took 64 balls for his 16.
Sachin took 98 balls for his 16.
Laxman took 29 balls for his 5.
Ganguly (it is tough to consider him as a batsman on present form) took 14 balls for his 2.

Total stagnation.

It’s also time that two of my favorite cricketers looked long and hard at their careers.

Ganguly. 48 runs in this series. It’s not just one series but even his most ardent fans (I am one of them) have to accept that his batting has undergone a decline. Once he was India’s main batsman after Sachin—-now he is India’s principal weak point. It is time Ganguly realized that his presence in the team can no longer be justified with a few in-form batsmen waiting in the wings. Despite some baffling game plans in the Bangalore test, he still remains India’s greatest Test captain but he no longer seems to be an automatic selection into the 11. Which is the principal criteria for selection of the captain.

Dada need to go back to the drawing board—-and prove himself at the first-class level before he is selected in the Test 11. Azhar went through this process and he came back stronger for it. It’s time for Dada to stand aside or be trampled underfoot.

Sachin Tendulkar. Greatest ever after Bradman. No doubt here. But it seems the man has become a victim of his own legendary status so much so that he has become obsessed with his personal achievements. The Mohali Test and Sachin’s selfish go-slow cost us the game there. And in Bangalore, Sachin’s biggest Achilles heel came to the fore—–when he need him the most he is usually not there.

Over here, with Sehwag gone he should have been looking to take the lead—score quickly and help the other batsmen to play around him. But what happened? He became ultra defensive (he played out 8 successive maidens) and ultimately got out softly…… this the way the greatest batsmen of the world plays? If this was Lara then I can bet my bottom dollar they he would have hit Windies out of trouble or at the very least died trying. Sachin did not even try—not even for a single delivery did he show any intentions of taking control.

It is time Sachin introspects too about his motivations for playing, whether he has been truly a “team man” of late and whether he really enjoys the game like he used to. In a way Sachin and Ganguly represent two sides of the same coin: one seems to have lost the aggression but not the skill…the other has his aggro intact but seems to have totally lost his abilities.

In the meantime, India has just drawn a Test series with a Pakistani side that, by far, has been the weakest to ever visit India. Even though technically it is not so, morally this is a huge defeat. And following a home series loss to Australia, it is time for a new direction and some sweeping changes.

7 thoughts on “The Same Old Story—India Lose

  1. Totally agree with you….well written….


  2. Well, if sachin gets out playing a shot, the comment is “There was no need for a shot.. he should retire”. If he gets out defending, “He should have played his natural game. He’s getting old. he should retire.”

    Of course, his average for the series was 50. I’m glad I’m not Sachin.

  3. I am not of the opinion that anyone criticizes Sachin nowadays for getting out while playing a shot. It is his ultra-defensive, statistics-driven batting that has led to him drawing flak. Even in his prime Sachin would get out cheaply due to rash strokes—none talked about his retirement then. I am not saying Sachin has lost it technically—-my contention is that mentally he is not playing for the team any longer

  4. He really played slow in the Mohali test. But even that was at 50% strike rate.. thats not so bad. The test was really lost because our bowlers bowled flatly on the last day.. not because Sachin played slow for a session. The bangalore test 4th innings… clearly that was a team decision cause everyone batted slow. The other innings were really good innings.

    Calling him selfish based on the 1 innings is doing injustice to him.

  5. If it was the team decision to go slow,then why was not Sehwag playing according to the “decision” ? What I believe is closer to the truth was that none of the batsmen who followed were confident enough to play their shots! If Sachin is the greatest player in the world, he should be “above” the pitch and opposition—at least to some extent. But here he caved in like Ganguly and everyone else—-I am confident he has the technique to have played like Sehwag—but he didnt !

    I am a huge fan of Sachin and just believe that he can do much better than what he is doing if he changes his attitude.

  6. Pingback: medicina ayurveda

Have An Opinion? Type Away

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close