The Bhodrolok and the Trinamool


“If none of us voted for Trinamool, how did they win?” When I got this message on Whatsapp from a friend, I couldn’t but help suppress a smile. It went on “Everyone I talked to are disgusted with Didi, and yet, how does it keep winning bigger and bigger every time.”

There was a time when those outside the state could not understand its politics, like how it kept voting for a moribund CPM government for over thirty years. Now even those inside don’t quite understand why.

But they should. They should understand it very well.

You see, when he uses the pronoun “us”, my friend is referring to a very small niche: Calcutta-based middle-to-upper-middle-class sub-class (scientific name: Bhodrolok) that congenitally suffers from an exaggerated perception of it’s own political influence. When they took the forefront of the fight against Buddhadeb over Nandigram, or felt they had, they had this expectation of “poriborton”, which was nothing but a projection of their fantasies of an Utopian Bengal onto someone (and I never tire of saying “I told you so”) who was an embodiment of the best, or the worst depending on your point of view, of the very political ethos they were ostensibly seeking a “poriborton” from.

And now that they see that things, for them and this is worth italicizing for them, have gone for the worse, they are angry and hurt in a “Maine Pyar Kyon Kiya” way, their rhetorical question laying bare a deeper truth.

That they have been made redundant politically.

Mamata Banerjee’s formula for success is the V 2.0 of the CPM’s. Unlike the Congress, where one particular surname eats up most of the fruit and throws the seeds and maggots to those below, CPM and now TMC flows down the fruits of power to the rank-and-file, with how much you get from the system being proportional to how much you put into it. So if you walk in a procession to Brigade Parade grounds you get two slices of toast, if you make your own banner you get a rosogolla to go with the toast, and if you provide muscle then you get your little syndicate, or as it is called “jobs for the boys” where all real-estate products and services have to be procured from select vendors blessed by the party else “I am sorry you are Maoist”. The biggest prizes of course go to to those that can bring blocks of votes—imaams and local clubs of lumpens, with compensation proportional to provided benefit.

Where the CPM differs from TMC and Didi is that the CPM, while playing this game, remained a party of bhadralok, or to be more specific, upper-caste, educated men in particular with a taste for caviar and wine and and Camus and Sartre and good Spanish literature. Hence their rhetoric and their metaphors were aligned perfectly with what the bhadralok were comfortable with hearing. Grabbing someone’s land and distributing it among party faithful sounds much cooler when it is called “land reforms” and leads to a case study in EPW than just “Maa Mati Manush”. Which is why Basu or Buddha would not be caught offering namaaz or making Yusuf Pathan dance or publishing the kind of verse Didi proudly puts her name to, because they were too bhodrolok for that.

Boddo barabari, they would say.

With Didi it is different. Unlike the CPM, her party has no ideology except unquestioned obeisance to Didi. In a way it is not much different from bowing to Lenin and Marx, but the bhodrolok felt more comfortable with the intellectual heft of that than the gigantic posters of Didi that dot the Calcutta cityscape without relent. Didi is many ways the ultimate testament to the establishment of a Communist society in Bengal, a proletariat ruler who wields absolute power with no tolerance for dissent and who shows big business their place (namely sends them out of the state), and yet she is too “telebhaja” and “Bangladesh is border of Pakistan” to be respected in the way Buddha and Basu were.

But Didi does not care. While she is open to throwing a buddhijibi a few scraps his way if he is willing to prostrate himself in a “Tohfa kabool ho” way, she knows that the Bengali intelligentsia are and have always been politically irrelevant. They do not vote in a bloc, and while they may carp in a few newspaper columns and generate more noise than votes, she can always dismiss them as media conshpirashy and her flock would have no problems with that. Far better to take oath in name of Ishwar and Allah, and by this get the undying gratitude of Park Circus without doing a single tangible thing for them, than to pine for bhadralok approbation.

After all, what’s the bhadrolok going to do? All they can do is to leave the state, as they do in thousands, every year. But come poll day, who are they going to vote for?

The CPM? That’s a brand beyond rescuing.

The Congress? Yes. Next.

The BJP?

Let’s see. On the face of it, it could be them. After all, they are primarily a middle-class party, or to use the proper term favored in Calcutta intellectual circles, a party of the petty bourgeoisie, that puts nationalism and development in its messaging. Except that the BJP has historically been perceived as a UP-Bihar party, whose obsession with temples and cow-protection and vegetarianism-as-a-surrogate-for-nationalism find no resonance in Bengal where even Brahmins eat meat. The BJP, to put it blandly, is a swear word among the bhodrolok of Bengal. The BJP also has really never taken Bengal seriously, and there is no greater testament to that than fielding P C Sarkar and Bappi Lahiri as candidates.


When you put Bappi Lahiri as a candidate, you are basically telling the electorate “We dont’ take ourselves seriously” and when you put P C Sarkar on the ticket, you are relying on magic to win the seat. Now with Roopa Ganguly and Babul Supriyo, they have crossed the joke-punchline level, though it will be years before they can seriously pose a challenge to Didi’s juggernaut.

So all that’s left for the bhodrolok is to raise their hands and wonder what happened, and then go and vote None of the Above on the day of the polls.

Welcome to poriborton. Welcome to obsolescence.

Do you have any problem?




22 thoughts on “The Bhodrolok and the Trinamool

  1. The sad state of affairs perfectly summarized. West Bengal gone down the drain. I genuinely feel very very sad.

  2. Abhishek Ghising May 30, 2016 — 6:56 pm

    The govt should pass a law which makes it necessary to act accordingly if NOTA gets the highest percentage of votes in a constituency

  3. brilliant stuff once again arnab – the damned poriborton came at the wrong bloody time – just when buddha babu was turning things around – – damn !!

  4. Thanks for writing. Why have you stopped blogging regularly, though?

    1. Books take up my time. Plus new job and new city.

  5. Fine analysis – as a probasi, I wondered how Didi could be returned with increased majority when as per the Telegraph (whose website is my main source of news from back home) – Bengal has been going to hell in a handbasket ever since one can remember! What I find even more dire than TMC winning is that there is no real alternative.

  6. Spelling mistake… it should be “poblem”.

  7. This is not only Bengal but the case in India as well. The educated middle class make up just 1 or 2% of the electorate.

  8. Bhadrolok/ Intelligentsia are irrelevant everywhere.

    1. And we agree! They’re the ones clamouring relentlessly and don’t even cast their vote.

  9. nice read

  10. conan mukherjee May 31, 2016 — 4:28 pm

    You are too dismissive of the tangible work that MB has done among the vulnerable. In general, in Calcutta, roads are cleaner, traffic is smoother. MB allowed Ola and Uber to ply their trade and liberate the bhadralok from clutches of unscrupulous taxi drivers – something unthinkable during subhash Chakraborty’s time. I think you are too far away and too enamored of Anandabazar to analyze this verdict!

    1. I have family living in Calcutta. They have eyes.

    2. Kolkata has among the more scrupulous taxi drivers in India from my experience, unless things have changed drastically in the past 15 years.

    3. > MB allowed Ola and Uber to ply their trade and liberate the bhadralok from clutches of unscrupulous taxi drivers …


  11. Rajorshi Koyal May 31, 2016 — 8:02 pm

    As you have mentioned the “bhadraloks” are diminishing in Bengal. The so called intellects have given way to the mighty iron men having ridiculous Utopian thoughts. If from philosophical point of view a truth is anything that is unchangeable then I really don’t know what it is when this government is in power.I have no rhetoric implication to the CPIM government over such an issue whatsoever.But I think Bengal has had enough of these regional parties and has undoubtedly failed to cope up with the open mindedness. I really do don’t know how far the AAP government is going to have its limbs on the other state and that the congress is very weak.It is only BJP that can come in.

  12. For all its obvious faults TMC is way better than CPM. They Openly do what CPM did under a veneer of sophistication. CPM was a horrible brutal dictatorship which routinely broke the law they pretended to uphold. At least Trinamool is openly corrupt, openly anti Hindu, openly anti national. At least they have no hypo racy. Now things are out in the open with no illusions. They are also helping rout CPM and Congress which is priceless.

  13. I wish to be bhadrolok but not good enough for that. I am probashi from all over other than paschim bangla .I cannot make the brains go pop corn or face wear million smiles or righteous anger. My english is as bad as modi’s humor and psephology as good as of a arnob drone or barkha could not have put it better.the obsolescence ! for once your humour is better than my politics . You made me laugh on myself in a long time.thanks.but West bengal shall have few to dry its tears for a while…

  14. Debasish Choudhury June 1, 2016 — 5:59 am

    I am not very conversant with the geography of Kolkata vis-a-vis the assembly constituencies. But when I look at the result, it seems as if almost all constituencies in Kolkata metropolitan area, barring one or two, have been won by Trinamool.

    When your friend says that none of “us” voted for Trinamool, how did this happen? Perhaps “us” did not vote for any other party as well. “Us” restricted themselves to watching Zee Bangla on election day.

  15. @GreatBong – Very well written as usual. Always enjoy your pieces for the wry humour that is your trademark! The question of “we” or “us” is pertinent. In general if you look at it – the malaise of law and order ( the lack of it) situation, the ‘bada badi’ in utsavs all around and the corruption in upper echeleons is what has bothered the badhralok. But if you go to the country side you will after a long time better road, street lights and water – things that matter for rural folk. Yes there are no jobs – but then you did not have basic amenities earlier and for the first time perhaps people have seen some change. In this win it was more the TINA factor then anything else. The ‘jote’ was on a plank of “you cannot vote for them” but did not spell the why “vote for me” clearly. At the end it was choice between who is the lesser problem of the two – and the choice was clear – apart from a few who chose NOTA.

  16. Naga Chiranjeevi June 2, 2016 — 9:10 am

    Reality is tougher & more gorier than imagination…. Couldn’t have been more truer.

    You’ve aptly summed up land reforms & jobs for boys.

    You are among the few liberal writers, who support Right of Centre thoughts.

    Request you to write about prostitution racket in & around Bengal. It is spine-chillingly tough reality, which has been going unabetted.

  17. The lack of alternatives in WB and TN was highlight of this election. Both principal parties in both these states are just the same. The accepted path to power has been so much established now that any alternative will be just change in the face but path will remain same. Irony of India is in a bygone era both claimed their supremacy on intellectual capital in India. This alternative is not an alternative (AINA) is such a shame.

Have An Opinion? Type Away

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close